As a property owner in Ashville, finding the right tenants is crucial to protecting your investment and ensuring a positive rental experience.

Effective tenant screening is the key to identifying responsible, reliable renters who will care for your property and contribute positively to the community. This comprehensive guide will walk you through the essential steps of tenant screening in Asheville, NC, helping you make informed decisions and minimize potential risks.

Verify Income and Employment

In Asheville's diverse economy, verifying a prospective tenant's income and employment is a critical first step. As a general guideline, a tenant’s income should typically be at least three times the rent to maintain affordability and minimize financial strain. Start by requesting recent pay stubs, typically covering the last two to three months.

For self-employed applicants or those working in Asheville's growing gig economy, you may need to review tax returns or bank statements for a clearer picture of their financial stability.

Contact the employer directly to confirm the applicant's employment status, job title, length of employment, and salary. Be aware of Asheville's seasonal fluctuations, particularly in tourism-related jobs, which might affect a tenant's income stability.

Check Credit History

A credit check provides valuable insights into an applicant's financial responsibility. Obtain written consent from the applicant to run a credit check, which will reveal their credit score, payment history, and any outstanding debts or bankruptcies. While a perfect credit score isn't always necessary, look for patterns of financial responsibility.

Two people sitting at a desk across from a financial advisor

In Asheville, NC, where the cost of living can be higher than in some surrounding areas, a strong credit history can indicate a tenant's ability to manage their finances effectively. Pay attention to the debt-to-income ratio and any history of late payments or collections.

Review Rental References

Contacting previous landlords is crucial in understanding a tenant's rental history. Prepare a list of specific questions about the tenant's payment history, property care, noise levels, and overall behavior. Don't just contact the current landlord, as they might give a positive reference simply to move a problematic tenant out.

Reach out to at least one or two previous landlords for a more objective view. Inquire about the tenant's respect for property rules and local regulations. This can be particularly important in areas with strict homeowners' associations or in Asheville's historic districts.

Conduct Background Checks

A thorough background check is essential for ensuring the safety and security of your property and other tenants. This should include a criminal history check and a search for any past evictions.

In North Carolina, landlords are allowed to consider criminal history, but it's important to have a consistent policy that doesn't discriminate.

Interview Prospective Tenants

Personal interviews, whether in person or via video call, can provide valuable insights that paperwork alone can't reveal. Prepare a list of standard questions to ask all applicants to ensure fairness and consistency.

During the interview, pay attention to the applicant's demeanor, communication skills, and how they present themselves. This can give you a sense of how they might interact with neighbors and handle property-related issues.

Two people sitting across from eachother while talking

Consider asking about their interest in the area, their familiarity with local ordinances (such as noise restrictions or recycling requirements), and their long-term plans. This can help you gauge their potential as long-term, responsible tenants.

Assess Rental History

A tenant's rental history can be a strong indicator of their future behavior. Look for a stable rental history with few gaps or frequent moves. Ask about the reasons for leaving previous rentals.

In such a competitive rental market, a positive rental history can be a strong point in an applicant's favor, especially if they have experience renting similar properties in the area.

Evaluate Pet Policies

Asheville's pet-friendly culture means many tenants will be pet owners. If you allow pets in your rental property, clearly outline your pet policy in the lease agreement. Consider factors such as size restrictions, breed limitations, and additional pet deposits or fees.

During the screening process, ask for details about the pet, including vaccination records and references from previous landlords regarding the pet's behavior.

Consider Occupancy Limits

Be aware of local occupancy limits and fair housing laws when considering the number of occupants for your property. These limits can vary depending on the size and layout of the rental unit.

During the screening process, communicate your occupancy limits to potential tenants. This can help avoid issues with overcrowding or unauthorized sublets down the line.

Review Application Completeness

A complete and accurately filled application is often indicative of a responsible tenant. Pay attention to how thoroughly and accurately the applicant has filled out the rental application.

Person reviewing a document

Look for any inconsistencies or missing information. If there are gaps, don't hesitate to ask for clarification.

A willingness to provide additional information or explain discrepancies can be a positive sign. Ensure that all necessary documents, such as proof of income, identification, and signed consent forms for background and credit checks, are included with the application.

Bottom Line

Effective tenant screening is a critical component of successful property management in Asheville, NC. By thoroughly vetting potential tenants through income verification, credit checks, background screening, and personal interviews, you can significantly reduce the risks associated with problematic tenants and ensure a positive rental experience for both landlord and tenant.

House In Order Property Management understands the unique challenges and opportunities of the Asheville rental market. Our experienced team can guide you through every step of the tenant screening process, from creating comprehensive application forms to conducting thorough background checks.

Contact us today to learn how we can help you maximize the potential of your rental investment in the beautiful mountain city of Asheville.