One of the most crucial decisions landlords often face is the type of lease agreement they should offer their tenants. As a landlord, this choice can significantly impact your rental business's profitability, stability and management.

Among the various leasing options, the month-to-month lease stands out as an intriguing choice. It offers flexibility not commonly found in traditional fixed-term leases. In this guide, House In Order Property Management will help you choose the best lease for your rental success.

What is a Month-to-Month Lease?

A month-to-month lease is a rental agreement that starts the tenancy with no predetermined end date. It provides ongoing occupancy until either the landlord or tenant decides to terminate the agreement.

What Are Fixed-Term Leases?

Fixed-term leases usually last for a predetermined period, commonly one year. The agreement locks the landlord and tenant for the duration unless there is a breach of contract or both parties agree to early termination.

Why Landlords Should Consider a Month-to-Month Lease?

The decision to offer a month-to-month lease should not be taken lightly as it shapes your property's desirability in the rental market. Here are the potential reasons why landlords might consider this type of lease:

  • Market Responsiveness: A month-to-month lease allows landlords to be highly responsive to the flow of the real estate market. Landlords can adjust the terms of lease more frequently according to the rental demand in the area.

  • Tenant Flexibility: These leases may attract a broader pool of potential tenants who seek housing that accommodates their flexible circumstances.


  • Quality Tenant Retention: By initially offering month-to-month leases, landlords can observe tenant behavior and payment reliability without long-term commitment.

  • Property Control: Landlords gain more control over their property as they can end a lease with relatively short notice if any circumstances related to property management change.

  • Potential for Higher Returns: As month-to-month leases offer tenants greater flexibility, landlords can often collect rent higher in amount as compared to similar properties under fixed-term leases. This can further offset the risks associated with tenant turnover.

  • Reduced Long-Term Risk: Landlords are not locked into long-term agreements that might leave them at a disadvantage if there were any economic changes. This reduces the risk of being stuck with below-market rental rates during inflationary periods.

  • Streamlined Eviction Process: In the rare event of a tenant being evicted, month-to-month leases can simplify the process as they typically require shorter notice periods and less stringent conditions for termination.

When Should Landlords Not Go for Month-to-Month Leases?

As a landlord, you should be cautious about offering month-to-month leases. Here are some scenarios where a month-to-month lease might not be the optimal choice:

  • Seeking Stability: If you prioritize a steady, predictable income to cover mortgages, property taxes and other fixed expenses, the potential for tenant turnover in month-to-month leases could pose a financial risk.

  • Low-Demand Markets: In areas with lower rental demand, securing long-term tenants can be more financially prudent than relying on the transient nature of short-term leases.


  • High Turnover Costs: Properties that require significant maintenance may not be suitable for month-to-month leases due to the increased financial and time investments needed each time a tenant departs.

  • Tenant Screening: Landlords who find the tenant screening process challenging may struggle with the quick turnaround time of month-to-month tenancies.

  • Administrative Burden: The administrative workload of managing month-to-month leases including constant advertising, screening new tenants and preparing the legal paperwork can be challenging for landlords managing multiple properties.

  • Seasonal Rental Markets: In areas with seasonal rental demand, landlords may prefer the security of fixed-term leases ensuring that income is not lost during the most lucrative times.

  • Legal and Regulatory Restrictions: Some regions have stringent regulations regarding rental agreements which could make the month-to-month leases less advantageous and more complex to manage legally.

  • Desire for Low Involvement: Landlords who prefer a more hands-off approach or those who live far from their rental property may find month-to-month leases to be inconvenient as the properties require much more involvement and mangement than fixed-term leases.

How to Know if Month-to-Month Leases Are Right for You?

As a landlord, determining whether a month-to-month lease is right for you involves a careful assessment of your goals, preferences and the circumstances of your rental market. Here are the necessary steps to help you make this decision:

Assess Your Financial Goals

A fixed-term lease may be preferable if your priority is stable and a predictable income. However, if you can handle variability and wish to maximize your rental income, a month-to-month lease could be an advantageous process.

Evaluate Market Dynamics

You should understand the local rental demand as high-demand markets may support month-to-month leases with less risk of vacancy. However, in lower-demand areas, the risks of turnovers could outweigh the benefits.

Consider Your Availability

Month-to-month leases usually require more involvement. If you cannot commit to this or if you prefer a more passive management role, a fixed-term lease is more suitable.

Examine Tenant Patterns

You should analyze the typical tenant profile in your area. If your property attracts transient populations or those seeking short-term accommodations, month-to-month leases can be an excellent fit.

Plan for Seasonal Fluctuations

If your rental property is in an area with seasonal rental demand, it's crucial to consider how month-to-month leases will align with these patterns.

Review Your Financial Cushion

You must evaluate if you have enough of a financial buffer to handle potential vacancies or unexpected maintenance issues that may arise with higher turnover rates.


While a month-to-month lease offers flexibility and can be beneficial in certain markets or situations, it also comes with a degree of unpredictability and potential for increased costs due to higher turnover.

Consider hiring a professional property manager like House In Order Property Management to enforce the best type of lease agreement for your rental business. With the necessary experience, our property managers can help you determine which strategy is best for you to maximize your profitability and minimize your risks.

Contact us today to learn more!